
How do we ever innovate in pensions when we are driven by the necessity to meet sales targets?
We need to be building partnerships to deliver workplace pensions to supplement the state pension. The words in the purple box are from the Unison website. It is hard to be that simple and many will laugh when reading this. We may laugh at how simple the likes of Glyn Jenkins , Terry Pullinger and other unionists I have learned from – make it!
This may be laughed at by those (like me) driven by the need to pay the bills but this is a question that lies much that the Pensions Regulator hints at in its work authorising workplace pensions in the UK.
Does “value for members” or the sales target come first?
All that a “pension provider” or “proprietor” is doing ( as members understand) is taking money from the workplace (via a payroll) and returning it to those who have bought a pension some time later.
But in the meantime there is much that can go on between those paying over money , those expecting it back and those doing the management. This relationship can best be described as a partnership.
There is no space for “sales” as this implies that one partner is looking to achieve an undue advantage. The employer may think they are “selling” an employee benefit , obtained at the advantage of the provider;- while the provider may well think it can take advantage of the member, through a lack of transparency. There may be collusion between provider and employer and if any of these occurs, then it will be the member who will suffer. Over time trust will break down and that will defeat the drive to create “value for members”.
This is why trustees are there, they protect members from collusion and disputes and offer balance to ensure that all three of these parties . This is how commercial master trusts have developed but I think it could be improved if members had better ways of protecting their best interests.
Sold down the river? Not in future.
The difficulty for trustees is that they do not negotiate their member’s rights to pensions nor the terms on which their members have their pensions paid. The members need an empowered representative. Unions should play that part – delivering a deal that works for employers, providers and pensioners.
I miss their absence in the workplace since auto-enrolment took over and the accrual of defined benefits wound down in the private sector.
It seems that there is no one who has had a meaningful say in how the reward for work is split. So many staff are offered the AE minimum contributions (8% of band earning of which the employer pays 3%). We all know that this could in many cases be more if deferred rather than immediate pay was agreed. But who is there to agree that? Sadly there has not been a discussion.
There simply hasn’t been the voice in the workplace that we see in countries as diverse as Australia and countries on the north-west of Europe. Aspects of the agreement to pay pensions from money sent by providers are in place in the Australian Super but not the payment of deferred income and the same can be said of the UK AE system.
We have examples of countries where employee representative work and others where such partnership is returning.
Sweden, Denmark and the Netherlands in particular have found ways to include employers , providers and members in one partnership and unions and advisers provide oversite and consult on the progress of the pension scheme. They work with trustees and with those that regulate the trustees. This is something that we can return to in the UK, it exists in the public sector where we still have collective pensions.
But for this partnership to return to corporate pensions, we must stop this unnecessary “salesmanship” that I see dominating the development of trust needed to make collective agreements develop. We need unions to be instrumental in the development of consultative platforms , representing members’ interests, ensuring they get the right balance between immediate and deferred pay and overseeing the behaviour of the proprietor or provider of the workplace pension.
We need trade unions able to represent members of workplace pension schemes
This is not a call for increased union trustees (though that could be a spin-off benefit). It is a call for unions to be central to the decisions taken by employer as to how to appoint and maintain their workplace pension (whether DC or CDC). I cannot call it anything more than a partnership agreement between all parties to deliver fairness through good governance.
It means an end to side-deals so that transparency is delivered by providers to employers and members. We need negotiation by Unions so that the pension schemes balance the needs of everyone, but most especially those members who currently get least representation.
Currently, the UK relies heavily on a narrow band of high earners—the top 10% pay 58.4% of all Income Tax—while…