This conversation is well worth half an hour of your time
Should governments be spending so much on pensions? In countries such as Italy, France and Spain, about one in four euros spent by the state goes towards public pensions.
In the UK one in 10 pounds buy pensions. Meanwhile, younger people are facing a higher likelihood of poverty in old age than those retiring now.
The FT’s chief data reporter and columnist John Burn-Murdoch joins host Soumaya Keynes to discuss: is this a short-term problem – or have the assumptions on which many countries base their retirement systems lost all relevance? And either way, what’s the fix?
Why spend so much on pensions
As public finances creak around the rich world, some are asking a question: why are we spending so much on pensions?
Some pensioners have an answer. They’ve paid in their contributions, and now it’s time to get back what they’re owed. Others think it’s a bit more complicated than that, including John Burn-Murdoch, who this week has written a Big Read now on my blog about how pensions ate everything and what to do about it.
What follows is a transcript of what is said and it sits on my blog because I want somewhere to conserve this train of thought. Listen to the broadcast first and consult with this transcript if (like me) you want to consult what’s said.
Soumaya Keynes; Thank you for being here. OK, so on a scale of one to 10, how well do you think state pension systems in the rich world are working right now?
John Burn-Murdoch; Give you a four.
Soumaya Keynes That’s quite close to five, the dreaded neutral number.
John Burn-Murdoch Hence the four, Soumaya.
Soumaya Keynes OK, four, I’ll take it. Why?
John Burn-Murdoch Because the amount of economic activity, the amount of government spending, the amount of money circulating — which is being eaten up by or absorbed by pensions every year — is going up in many, many, many countries, and it has been going up for decades.
And I think this is starting to have a corrosive effect on the sense of the social contract, on social cohesion, on how much money the government can spend on other things, and even on things like intergenerational inequality.
Soumaya Keynes OK. So it is essentially your contention, then, that governments in the rich world are spending too much on pensions?
John Burn-Murdoch I think my contention is that it really would be useful for a lot of people to look at these statistics in the cold light of day and ask: do we think this system is doing the best it can for everyone?
And there may be some countries where they are not strictly spending too much overall in pensions, but the trajectory over the coming years could be tweaked in a way that could help some people and help government finances as a whole without hurting others.
But I certainly think there are some countries as well where spending levels have simply got too high and some more radical reforms might be necessary.
Soumaya Keynes OK. Well, can you give us an order of magnitude? How much are rich countries spending on state pensions?
John Burn-Murdoch So some countries are spending far, far, far more than others, and some countries are seeing steep increases while others are actually seeing declines. So the poster children, I would say, of spiralling pension spending would be countries like Italy, France and Spain, who are spending about one in four euros that the government spends on anything on pensions.
So those are huge numbers. They are, in some cases, about double what they were in 1980. In countries like the UK, we’re sort of middle of the road, so 11 per cent, about £1 in £10 the British government spend goes on pensions.
That’s still significantly more than is spent on many other things that we think of as critical public services. But there are interesting cases like Sweden, Denmark, Australia, where the share of total spending is lower and is actually flat or even slightly falling. So this is not a universal story, but there are some striking cases where things are getting pretty bad.
Soumaya Keynes What about the US? Where does that sit in this story?
John Burn-Murdoch So the US is somewhere in the middle here. The share of GDP being spent on pensions at the moment is about 7.5 per cent, so that’s much lower than your France and Spain, but it’s higher than some other countries. It’s also significantly higher than it was about 25 years ago when it was 5.5 per cent.
And the way the system there works is that nominally this is about social security contributions in a given year are paid in, social security payments to pensioners come out. That sounds like a sort of classic contributory system, but it has been in deficit for some time now.
So there is about 20 per cent more being paid out than paid in at the moment, which means the social security trust fund in the US, where all these accumulated surpluses in the past were stored, is being rapidly depleted.
That is on course to be exhausted entirely in 2032, and at that point, it is likely that the US will become very much a pay-as-you-go system in the truest sense, like everywhere else: money in, money out, and they will have to find other sources of revenue, whether that is from raising taxes or shifting state spending from elsewhere to fill that gap.
Soumaya Keynes OK. So, pressures from an ageing society everywhere. And, just to be clear here, because, you know, pensions can cover quite a lot, we are talking about state pensions, right?
We are not talking about public sector pensions. We’re not talking about pensions being paid to teachers, firefighters, doctors, and we’re also not talking about sort of very targeted poverty measures, right? So, you know, you might have housing benefit for people who can’t afford housing. That would not be included in your pension spending number.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah. This is strictly what we in the UK would call the state pension or in the US, old-age social security.
So this is payments that you get based on how old you are, the fact that you’re no longer in work, might include, like, survivors’ benefits. And to the extent that it includes means-testing payments, it would still be things that are strictly considered an old-age pension.
Soumaya Keynes OK. So, you were just saying that over the decades, spending on the state pension has risen, and there are two reasons potentially for that, right?
One, you could just have a larger eligible population, maybe more people have become eligible, maybe there are just more pensioners because a particular cohort is bigger, maybe people are just living longer.
Or it could be that actually you’re paying out more per pensioner, right? So maybe the benefits, the pensions that you’ve promised to people have become more generous. Do you have a sense of which of those two it is?
John Burn-Murdoch So it’s gonna depend on exactly when and where we’re looking, but a few decades ago, it was mainly increasing generosity per pensioner payment. Now it is mainly demographic.
Soumaya Keynes OK. So, framing the issue here, we have ageing populations, which means that per working-age person, there are just more old people to support, and if there was loads of growth, that would be really easy, but bad news, there isn’t.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah, so it’s really hard to talk about this without descending into intergenerational warfare. But from the perspective of young people, in many cases, they’re not expecting the same kind of pensions that the older generation are getting, but they’re still being expected to fund the current bill.
So it totally makes sense why some people do view this as a sort of young-versus-old dynamic.
Soumaya Keynes OK. But I suppose there is an argument that it’s not the pensioners’ fault that there are so many of them, right? And they were made promises, and this is what it costs to have a functioning society, where you have a reasonable state pension system delivering on its promises. What’s the comeback to that?
John Burn-Murdoch I think one problem is that those promises were made based on policymakers’ assumptions, which haven’t held true. So a lot of policymakers were expecting the kind of steady 2, 3 per cent wage growth, economic growth that we were seeing at that time to continue.
We haven’t, so that has put downward pressure on payments into the system. I think there was also, again, a failure to appreciate what would happen to life expectancy, so just . . . We didn’t realise quite how big that ageing bulge would be.
But I do think there is maybe a broader societal discussion to be had in terms of: are pensions actually about this sort of return of what people paid in? Should they be more of a basic income support to ensure a good, dignified level of living standards into old age compared to what they’ve become now, which is, in some cases, really quite substantial payments to people and households who are already very financially secure independently in their own retirement.
The way all of that looks now is just quite different to what it was when these systems were drawn up. So just to put some numbers on this, in the middle of the 20th century, when a lot of these policies were really getting under way or really picking up steam, pensioners were by far the lowest income group in society.
They had cripplingly high poverty rates, as high as 50 per cent in some countries, and they often still had rent to pay. Home ownership was significantly lower among those groups.
They had pretty much the lowest living standards of any demographic in terms of how you’d usually look at this. Fast-forward to the 2020s, and you’ve got higher home ownership rates, which reduce the amount of money that’s needed to just keep housing going.
They have got significantly higher incomes through the combination of public and, in many cases, private pensions. And if you now look at living standards as defined by the total amount per person that a household is consuming, in a lot of countries, pensioners are now at the top of the pyramid instead of the bottom.
Soumaya Keynes Yeah. I mean, look, maybe it’s worth stepping back now and sort of clarifying what the point of a pension system is. Well, first of all, there are two different types of system, right? So we have a Beveridgean system. So that’s the one that the UK has, right?
Which is this universal state pension that’s pretty flat. It goes to everyone, and it’s really meant to be there to provide this floor, this income floor that you do not sink below when you hit retirement, and, you know, meant to maintain minimum dignity levels.
And within that system, you’ve got some redistribution within the generation of pensioners, right? So maybe, you know, the poorer ones are getting the same amount as the richer ones. And so, if you’re looking at that compared to how much tax they paid in during their lifetime, that looks like a redistribution towards the poor.
There’s a different kind of pension system, though, called a Bismarckian pension system, and the first one there was set up in the 1880s in Germany. And there the idea is actually that the state has a role in helping people to redistribute money over their lifetimes. You know, we save when we’re young, we get a pension when we’re old. And the idea was that actually the state can help you do that.
And those are two perfectly fine things for a pension system to try to do. But under that second one, it will look as though some rich people are getting a pension, right? I wonder if we should be careful about not sort of mixing those two.
John Burn-Murdoch So yeah, if we want to break down which system which countries have, these days, a lot of them are a bit of a hodgepodge. But if we really wanna look at some cleaner examples, the UK is essentially Beveridgean, whereas France, Spain, and even the US are more Bismarckian.
So they are in the business of redistributing someone’s own income over their own lifetime. So in those systems, people who had higher earnings are gonna get higher pensions in the end. So yeah, I agree it is worth emphasising that those are quite different systems with different goals.
Soumaya Keynes And then the other point is that baked into all these pension systems is a sense that you’re also redistributing across generations, right? So, you know, in the middle of the 20th century, you had redistribution towards the generation who, say, fought in the second world war.
They were going to be a poorer generation than the generations that were younger, right? And so it kind of made sense: redistribute from a richer generation to a poorer, older generation. And so here I’m actually kind of gonna agree with the analysis, which is that, maybe now the challenge is that actually we’re not sure that today’s younger generations necessarily are going to be much, much richer than the older ones.
And so that idea of redistribution becomes a bit weaker.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah. I mean, totally agree with you, and I think it is really important to say here: the policies we’re talking about here, not only were they well-intentioned, they did actually make sense.
It’s just that there have been these big economic and demographic shifts since then — the ageing populations, the slower wage growth — which mean that whether you have a Beveridgean or a Bismarckian model, the sums have started not to add up.
In addition, we do see plenty of countries, often literal neighbouring countries, that have very different outcomes because they have made quite modest, quite reasonable tweaks to their system over the decades, which have meant they’ve been able to avoid the situation of a country like France, where pensions take up ever more of GDP without anyone feeling swindled.
Soumaya Keynes Yeah, I mean, what do you think of this? This is my sort of potted history of state pensions over the last few decades. So, you know, second half of the 20th century, there’s this real problem of pensioner poverty. And so you see reforms, you know, between, say, the fifties and maybe the mid-seventies where governments are really increasing the generosity of pensions.
But as you say, that was based on assumptions that didn’t turn out to be accurate, right? People ended up living much longer than they predicted, which meant that their state pension promises were much more expensive. And then that kind of interacted with other fiscal constraints to mean that then over the next few decades, governments gradually started to row back some of these promises.
Now, because pensions are by their nature something that, you know, they require a lot of planning, people make long-term plans around them, it’s very difficult to make them less generous quickly, right? Because you risk screwing over people who’ve made long-term decisions. And so what governments did is said, OK, great. Well, we’re not going to completely whip the carpet out under the feet of some of these people who we’ve made these promises to, but we’re gonna curb entitlements to the younger people.
But what that left is a sort of group of people who actually had these promises made to them that went bad, and then it was the younger generation who was asked to make those promises good.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah.
Soumaya Keynes And now, you know, some of what we’re seeing is demographics. Some may just be the consequences of those earlier decisions about the transition towards these less generous pensions. And actually, maybe those earlier decisions . . . maybe some people feel that those are unfair.
John Burn-Murdoch; Yeah, one thing I’d say at this point is: one of the ways in which governments can say the sums aren’t working out the way we thought they would, so we need to, just make the increases a bit less generous, ’cause as you say, you don’t wanna give everyone a cliff edge.
One solution is that. But another thing that governments have essentially done, to my reading of the data at least, is shifting spending from other government-provided goods and services into pensions. So a lot of countries that have an explicitly contributory system, where payments in were earmarked to be paid out, when those sums stopped adding up, they have had to shift spending from infrastructure, from, in some cases, education or defence.
It’s hard to say that something was an exact one-to-one shift, but we have seen the share of spending on pensions go up and up and up. Share of spending on the kind of goods and services that younger people benefit more directly from have gone down. And that strikes me as a little bit of a way of saying, well, we can’t give pensioners an unpleasant shock, and I think that’s entirely reasonable. But we are, in effect, gonna give the broader younger population a shock. It’s just that people might take 20 years to realise that things are crumbling a bit.
Soumaya Keynes Are there any examples where this is super obvious?
John Burn-Murdoch So the example where I think this is clearest is in Spain, where the amount of money that the government collects from workers in taxes has gone up. So workers see that and think, right, the government’s taking more of my money. But the amount of money the government spends on pensions has gone up by even more. So taxes increase, all of them, and more go on pensions, and to make up for that gap, the government cuts spending on your infrastructure, education, defence.
Soumaya Keynes Right, maybe I should point out here, though, that, you know, working out how much redistribution is going on between generations is really hard. Because, you know, in the moment it looks like, oh, well, the young are paying the pensions for the old, but obviously when the young age themselves, someone else is gonna be paying their pensions.
We don’t know how much pension they’re going to get in future. So, you have to be really careful about making really big claims about redistribution between generations. But in the short term, the trends that you describe do sound quite challenging. OK, let us cut to a break now, and when we get back, I’m gonna ask you what you wanna do about all of this.
So, John, you want to cause riots in the streets by slashing state pensions. How exactly would you like to do that?
John Burn-Murdoch Exactly right. No, look, this is one of those areas where one can look at where we are, and one can look at where we might ideally be, but getting from A to B is not at all straightforward. So some of the countries that seem to be weathering this sort of demographic storm, as it were, better than others, are ones that haven’t necessarily made a lot of radical tweaks over the last decade or two, but they actually set things up in a completely different way.
But if it just helps to talk about one such example, just to give us an idea of how different things could be, I find Australia really interesting here, because usually if we’re talking about something that’s concerning people in one anglophone country, it means it applies everywhere. But Australia, because they had high rates of home ownership right back in 1908 when they set out their state pension, their old age pension, they said from the start that if you were independently financially secure, you didn’t receive their old age pension. And for essentially 120 years, that has been an understanding.
So although the specifics, the thresholds have changed over time, they’ve always had a system that says this is about providing that minimum floor, and as their private sector pensions have become more substantial, gradually fewer Australian pensioner households have had to rely on the state.
The question, as I say, is how you get there. One thing that I think certainly a lot of the Southern European countries should be looking at a lot more than they are at the moment is relying more on private sector pensions. So essentially, we’re trying to resolve the tension here between not wanting to actively decrease the amount of income that older people are receiving while having that take less of a toll on the state. And I think the most straightforward way of doing that is to rely more on private sector pensions, which can ensure that that income in old age stays substantial, but just means that the state is carrying less of that burden.
Soumaya Keynes OK. Well, I have so many thoughts. So you want to move everyone away from that Bismarckian system where there’s some kind of earnings replacement, and instead get the private sector to do that.
John Burn-Murdoch So I would stop short of saying everyone, but I think in countries such as France and Spain, where the Bismarckian systems are now very, very heavily unbalanced, and the deficits in terms of earmarked contributions to spending have got wider and wider, I think that would be an interesting policy to pursue.
Soumaya Keynes Let’s go through this systematically, right? So there are different things you could do if you are concerned about high state pension system spending. So number one, you could follow Australia, and you could means-test it, right? You could say, you know, if you have income over a certain level, then you are not eligible for the state pension. As you alluded to, the issue is in the transition, right? Australia just had that system from the start, right? And it’d be very, very challenging to do that for current working-age people where they have worked for a certain period of time in expectation of a certain income in retirement that is now being whipped away from them. That would feel very unfair.
They might make different decisions had they done that. There are all sorts of other issues when it comes to means-tested pension spending, right? So one is: you’re effectively punishing people for saving for their own retirement, right? So you could get two pensioners, right?
One spent their whole life going out on the town, partying it up, spent all their money, and now lives off the state. Another one, you know, spent their life living frugally, saving for retirement, and then now they don’t get that state income, right? And that could feel very unfair to people. Another challenge with means-tested pensions is that you’re effectively forcing the population to wade through a huge amount of paperwork to get their benefits, right? So Australians have to fill in, you know, an 120-question form if they want to access these benefits.
Richer people find it easier to fill in the forms because they have the wherewithal. You could end up disincentivising saving, right? Which is related to the first point I mentioned. But then also just that fundamental point about . . . in the transition, unless you do it with, like, a 50-year notice period, you’re taking money away from people who planned assuming they would have that money, and a 50-year notice period for a pension reform is no good because you’re getting all the political grief and you don’t even save any money for 50 years. So yeah, what’s your defence of a means-tested pension system?
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah. I mean, as I say, it’s a very difficult transition to handle, and any tweaks that you’re making along these lines would have to be very incremental. As you say, it could be something that literally takes a couple of decades. But I think just given the fact that countries that have got to that destination are in a much, much, much better position, and they have less of that sort of intergenerational social strife and that whole dynamic as well, I think it’s something at least worth considering. But I certainly wouldn’t say that we should only look at one method. I mean . . .
Soumaya Keynes Well, I actually have a comeback, though, there, because, you know, arguably, when William Beveridge set up the state pension system in the UK, which is, you know, universal and this flat-rate benefit, he hated means-testing, right? The idea was that everyone would get this benefit, rich and poor, and that would really, you know, contribute to the social fabric, right?
And actually, if the rich were getting it, they might fight harder to protect it. And once you means-test something, then it’s maybe more vulnerable to being cut later on. So there is a kind of, you know, a social value maybe. I mean, maybe that’s just an argument that pensioners would make, so. John Burn-Murdoch No, I mean, that’s clearly true, but I think there are a couple of things here.
I mean, a lot of the countries we might consider of as being especially concerned about universality and social cohesion, like some of the Nordics, are some of the countries that have at least significant parts of their pension systems means-tested. Additionally, I think . . .
Soumaya Keynes Can I just push back on that? Do they really have big shares of their pension system that are means-tested, or is it just, you know, there’s a bit of a means-tested top-up? I mean . . .
John Burn-Murdoch So in Denmark, for example, there are essentially two tiers. The basic level is given to everyone, and then the supplementary level is means-tested against income. And for a single pensioner, that second one is actually larger than the first. Now, that is, again, single pensioners rather than couples who live together. But there’s significant parts of those systems.
And again, I think maybe because they do still retain that universal minimum support that reduces some of the concerns you’re talking about, and that is perhaps what we would need to talk about here, not a complete removal of a basic state pension for everyone, but a gradual separation into systems, so we start to at least talk about this poverty eradication aspect and then an additional bit which is about topping you up to a more reasonable level above that, which could be tested against income and assets.
Soumaya Keynes Yeah. I mean, it sounds that you’re just really a Beveridgean at heart, and you just don’t really believe in the Bismarckian principle that actually the state could have a role to make sure that people can have a sort of smooth income, you know, not too much of a drop between when they’re working and when they’re retired. And I guess, to be clear, I would love to be in a system where the state took on some of the risk that I am now being forced to take on as an individual.
I think that, you know, the state can have this big role in helping to redistribute over the life cycle. Now, clearly, it needs to be tweaked and, you know, you need to have some kind of semi-automatic or regular updates to make sure that you haven’t accidentally got your assumptions really, really badly wrong. But I’m open to it.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah. I mean, I am. I think that’s an accurate characterisation of me. I think I am Beveridgean in that sense, but for me, the modern and more fiscally sound Bismarckian approach is to increasingly or steadily rely more on private pensions to do that. I think if we wanna soften that cliff at the end of one’s career, have that be set by your own earnings invested in a pension fund rather than by the state, which is where things seem to have gone wrong for some of the most Bismarckian systems.
Soumaya Keynes You’re just trying to take my state pension away, aren’t you? I mean, I don’t have a Bismarckian state pension system. I live in the UK, so. OK, one final question about your other favourite method of reducing pension eligibility, which is raising the state pension age, which is a reasonable thing to do.
You can’t necessarily increase it one for one with life expectancy, though, right? Because some people cannot work when they get old, and if you’re increasing it, then you’re effectively penalising people with shorter life expectancies who tend to be poorer, right? And that kind of goes the wrong way with your redistribution aims.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah, I mean, this one is messy and there are other things as well. Like, there’s really interesting research that shows that when older workers stay longer in the workforce, that can block progression for younger workers. So if to the extent that we’re doing this because of an intergenerational unfairness aspect, by having people work longer, you can end up even exacerbating that, or at least not helping it.
So I, again, I don’t think this is super simple, but what I like about some of the methods — again, it’s often the Nordics are doing, and in the UK even has a version of this now — is you link the pension system, both the age and even the generosity, to life expectancy in such a way that unless anyone kicks off every few years, there will be natural adjustments made.
Again, not one for one, but they will ensure that you’re not going too far off piste unless someone intervenes politically. So I think just making as much of the pension system as possible directly linked to demographics, to economic trends, in such a way that the spirals that happened early on don’t get repeated — I think that would just be a very sensible idea.
Soumaya Keynes Nice technocratic process that removes the politics from the extremely controversial decision of when you’re allowed to retire.
John Burn-Murdoch But I think it is a rare case where that seems to be true. I mean, France seems to have this problem because this was not something that happened automatically. So every time there is discussion of the pension age, it becomes a huge thing. So yeah, I think just turning something into a spreadsheet seems to be one way to go.
Soumaya Keynes You like spreadsheets? What a shock. OK. Well, look, this is a fun conversation because it’s quite rare that I disagree with someone I like so much. I suppose if the challenge is that some of the state pension spending that we’ve got today is the result of intergenerational redistribution, right?
So there’s just a particular generation; they had these promises made to them, and their entitlements are now sort of more generous than the state can support, then the solution to that is probably some kind of reduction in entitlement now? But that’s so politically painful to enact, right?
And so where that pushes you is: OK, well, we have to do this over decades, right? Maybe we gradually introduce some kind of means-testing. You and I can disagree on that, but, you know, you phase in these reforms over a very long period of time, but then you kind of end up with the problem in the first place, right?
Which is that you still have a generation who is protected because of the nature of pensions, because these things take so long to plan, because people feel so viscerally upset about having money that was promised to them taken away from them. So yeah, it feels like we haven’t really resolved this kind of very fundamental political problem, which is that at some point there might be a zero-sum fight here between people within a generation, people across generations. There are no easy answers.
John Burn-Murdoch No, I mean, I agree, and I do think the solutions here, the workable solutions here, are incremental. To the extent that I’m diagnosing an immediate problem in some areas, I don’t think there is an equally immediate solution. The more immediate things that can be done would be around, for example, the pension age, where what we are doing is, yes, you’re asking someone to work for a year longer, and that is, again, there’ll be a huge amount of argument that that should be done to anyone, let alone, as you say, to people who have fewer healthier years after they retire.
But that at least is something where you are not saying to someone, we will give you less money. The amount that is in your pension check will go down, even though that is what happens in aggregate. So I do think there are some more short-term things that can be done, like for every year France increases its state pension age, it would save about a third of a per cent of GDP every year perpetually.
And there are examples in the past, so Sweden in the 1990s faced a bit of a pensions crisis. They made immediate changes to the indexation method, which again have compounded it. They’ve maybe taken a couple of decades to really start paying dividends. But I do think whether incremental or a little bit punchier in terms of things like the pension age, there are things that other countries have done that can work, and it won’t be a fix overnight, but it might be a fix that in a generation’s time means this conversation has changed.
Soumaya Keynes Yeah, I guess just final point, you know, when reading the discourse in pensions land, it feels like the thing that’s really freaking out policymakers is adequacy, right? It’s actually . . . We’ve now got systems where we’ve said, OK, great. You go and build up private pensions because we’re curbing the generosity of the state pension system, and actually people just haven’t built up very big private pensions.
And so there’s just real fears that the generations, you know, coming down the pipeline who are going to retire in the next few decades are just gonna not have very much to live on, right? And which is, you know, this is the trade-off, right? You can have very expensive pensions that give you lots of money to retire on, or you can have very cheap but very inadequate pensions.
John Burn-Murdoch Yeah, absolutely. I mean, again, it’s one of the strange things here. We’re talking about pensions perhaps being too generous when the share of young people, people in their thirties, forties today, who risk being in poverty as pensioners is, if anything, going up. I mean, the number of people who will be renting in the private sector when they retire is gonna be much higher than it was for people who are retired today.
And yeah, there’s absolutely an unevenness issue here. There are wealthy pensioners who, in my view, don’t necessarily need a state pension, but there are lots and lots and lots of pensioners who are on the brink of poverty, and that number is, if anything, going to increase.
So one of the places my willingness to consider means-testing comes from is that pensioner outcomes are so different within a generation. And so anything that ensures that the people who are having the toughest time within the generation of pensioners are supported, while perhaps reducing the level of state support for those at the other end, I think should be on the table.
Soumaya Keynes OK. Well, I’ll be on the barricades defending my pension from you.
John Burn-Murdoch I’ll see you there.
Soumaya Keynes John, thank you so much for joining me.
John Burn-Murdoch Thank you.
[…] it’s a bit more complicated than that, including John Burn-Murdoch, who this week has written a Big Read now…