How pensions ate the state – a big read

It is such a good article that I’m posting a “free link” to it, here it is. Here are the numbers produced by the FT’s in London. More free reads are available if this one runs out – henry.h.tapper@gmail. It’s sensational headline gives way to a less emotive but equally important one!

Retirees once had by far the highest poverty rates, now they have the lowest

What is showing all over the western world is that those who are 65 or older are now as likely to be involving financial poverty as those under 65. None of the four charts tell us that we have not made a success out of rewarding those who make it to their pension.

This is the macro-financial reality! John starts by explaining the situation when these charts began. It was the time that people like me were being born and we have lived booming lives.

While the boomers are retired or retiring there is a legacy of pension promises still to be funded. It is bad in the UK but twice as bad in European countries which rely on “pay as you go” rather than a mix of funded and unfunded pensions.

What this has led to is the kind of social warfare we’ve seen in Europe this summer with words turning to actual violence. The situation abroad is worse than it is at home

As lengthening lifespans swell the ranks of recipients, falling birth rates and weak wage growth are limiting contributions into the system.

It is particularly worrying if you’re in France or Spain. Germany is making moves to put its pension system on more of a funded basis while America and Japan have their own problems.

Looking at the chart for the UK , we should feel relatively proud. We are doing something to meet our obligations to those generations yet to near retirement.

But look around and you can see that there’s a problem for the young in subsiding their parents and grandparents.

In the UK and US, public spending on pensions is now equivalent to a 20 per cent slice of the workforce’s pre-tax wages, up from 10 per cent in 1970. Please remember this 20% contribution rate to our welfare system when you call for mandatory contributions to funded private pensions at a further 12%.

Today’s retirees receive far more in state pension payments than they paid in during their working lives.

We (the UK)  have at least gone some way to mitigating the cost to future generations , in others the problems for youngsters are more acute (and they know it)

A higher disposable income today but not for those coming behind. Two-thirds of Spain’s GDP growth since 2008 has gone to pensions

In the UK, around one in five 18-34s is behind on some or all household bills, compared with one in 40 over-65s.

If there was such a thing as “financial happiness” this would chart it!

The next half of this amazing report looks at what is going on in certain countries (and not in others). It looks at Denmark, Australia, Sweden , the US and yes – the United Kingdom and does what I haven’t seen done elsewhere. It looks at sustainability, fairness and the ways of getting there. I will look at that tomorrow – the second day of a late November weekend!

 

Unknown's avatar

About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in pensions and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to How pensions ate the state – a big read

  1. Derek Scott's avatar Derek Scott says:

    The FT article is right to highlight intergenerational inequality, but its framing is misleading.

    Pension expenditure isn’t money simply “eaten” by the state: it’s a social commitment, and the more important unanswered question is how fairly that can be better financed and redistributed.

    Some affluent pensioners undoubtedly receive more public support than they need.

    But that doesn’t justify treating all retirees as privileged, or assuming that means-testing and private pensions for all are the answer.

    Funded pensions carry investment and other risks, while means-testing can penalise saving and in some cases misses health or mental issues.

    Nor can weak wage or salary incomes, unaffordable housing for many and declining public investment in things that matter, simply be blamed on pensioners.

    These reflect wider political and economic choices and mistakes made in the past.

    The objective should be security in retirement for all, with greater contributions or sacrifices from those best able to afford them, not a generational tug-of-war.

    Pension reform is necessary, but it must go hand in hand with fairer incomes, more housing and better targeted public investment, far too much of which seems to be squandered in so many different ways.

    Otherwise, we will simply be redistributing some poverty and health insecurity challenges, rather than solving them.

  2. Pingback: Pensions ate everything ; are the assumptions that gave us our pensions systems still right? | Pensions Mutual; Making your money work as hard as you do

It makes my day to have your comments!