So long as the industry puts itself first – we’ll always have billions in tiny pots.

This blog is about the inanity of the pension industry’s plans to get small pot consolidation. What you are about to read is from Professional Pensions and was written by Alex Levy. Alex is new to pension journalism so may not be aware of the 20 years that the pensions industry has been ringing its hands over small pots. They cost everyone a fortune in levies and grow each year as people join schemes and leave soon after.

Alex must however be scratching his head as to how pot consolidation is ever going to happens so long as the pensions industry is obsessed by decades of fresh complexity. The headline says all that you need to read, but read on to find my solution to all this nonsense. It won’t cost much and will rely on people’s apathy to the pension features that their pensions were sold on!

Let’s list the ten reasons why we can’t get on with consolidating small pots into bigger pots (or even collective pensions).

  1. mis-selling (a coverall but this is especially worrisome when DC microplots head towards CDC)
  2. discretionary powers for schemes to decide which pots with guarantees fall within scope of consolidation
  3. pots worth more than £1,000 or likely to be (with the right wind in the sails)
  4. active in the last 12 months making them ineligible for consolidation
  5. micro-pots that can be exchanged for guaranteed annuity rates,
  6. or have survivor benefits,
  7. pots that carry protected pension ages (so can be taken at 55 not 57)
  8. small pots which have enhanced tax-free cash (presumably calculated when part of a DB or CDC occupational pension
  9.  the rights of the pot may be contingent on marriage or civil partnership….
  10. TISA  says “providing schemes with discretion over the eligibility of pots containing guarantees is likely to result in inconsistent outcomes for consumers and create potential liability concerns for schemes.”

All 10 may all be valuable despite a pot’s small monetary size and so make the pot ineligible for consolidation

But the cost of working out all these exemptions will be so high that consolidation might not be worth it and eligibility for consolidation may  be kicked a further few years down the road.

Specialist law firm Sackers called for a government rethink over its proposal that trustees and providers should decide whether to consolidate pots with these features.

Partner Ferdy Lovett said that “the costs and administrative burden” of using these discretionary powers “could quickly become disproportionate to the value of the pots”.

Well there you have it.

The SPP called for an “industry-developed catalogue of protected rights, consistent classification standards and clearer regulatory guidance” to reduce the risk of members losing these benefits through “incomplete historical records” or “administrative errors“.

AKA – do nothing unless you want to risk your profitability or even your status as a pension provider.


 

My alternative way of dealing with small pots

Once we have a pensions dashboard everyone knows where every small pot is. Some code is invented that flashes up a warning whenever a pot appears saying that

“this pot is in danger of being consolidated and this will happen if you don’t take action”

We cannot afford to investigate whether your little pot is worth you keeping but if you want to find out for yourself, here is a number and a weblink that will take you to someone at your provider (now you’ve found it). They will explain to you the features of your pot that you may want to keep.

If you want to keep your small pot(s), you can do so and you can action this by filling out this form which is a disclaimer meaning you are happy to miss out on the benefit of having all your money in one place.

There should then follow a list of features that may be features embedded in the pot and another list of all the advantages of doing nothing and being consolidated.

Based on human nature, this will lead to a few people sending in the form and sorting things out with those managing their pots. Rather more will fill in the form but then doing nothing. The vast majority of people will ignore the form and be consolidated and if anybody moans after that, they can be told they had the chance to look into it and they didn’t.

You think this is a fantasy – you think right! People who go on the pension dashboard and read the warning about small pots will be a small proportion of people and the majority will never have the warning. The vast majority will pay the immense price of losing the features if they had them (which they’ll never know).


Why do I propose this?

It’s because the pension industry has become so up itself that it has forgotten what it’s there for. It has given the keys to the lawyers who are driving up and down at our expense until the petrol tank is empty.

It will take some ridiculous plan to be put in place till people see sense and realise that the features on these small pots are seldom if ever used and only by people who are massively engaged with their affairs.

What the pension industry needs to get on with, is simplifying the horrible mess that people may find their pension affairs are in  when they see their pension dashboard. The way out of this misery is something as daft as I’m proposing.

Unknown's avatar

About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in pensions and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

It makes my day to have your comments!