
This by email from Philip Stafford
Prime Minister Andy Burnham was at the Guildhall last night, laying out his plans for a reset in UK-EU relations at a summit in Brussels on Friday.
From the tone of his speech, there was very little for bankers, executives and lawyers to worry about in any upcoming negotiations.
While Burnham said
“we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years” since the Brexit vote, he acknowledged that “some sectors like financial services and tech have adapted well and are thriving.”
The financial services industry largely takes the view that it is too big to become a ‘rule taker’ from anywhere else.
And while some parts of the UK economy, in chemicals, foodstuffs or car parts, may look for a closer alignment with the EU, in financial services the two sides have steadily grown apart over the past six years.
Anyone hoping for an immediate ‘bonfire of the inanities’ of EU rules was always going to be disappointed: Britain had been highly influential in the crafting of European regulations. Both sides were also signed up to a host of post-2008 global standards on bank capital and derivatives markets.
Notwithstanding these perimeters, both sides made protection and strategic autonomy of their financial services a priority.
Brussels aimed to prevent business from leaking to London by restricting the series of permits known as equivalence, which oversee cross-border activity in areas such as accounting, insurance, capital requirements, trading and clearing.
EU institutions can access overseas markets if Brussels deems the local rules to be of a similar standard to those of the EU. Even countries such as Indonesia, Mexico, Saudi Arabia and China have far more equivalence permits than the UK.
Moreover, the UK has been active in reviewing the EU rules. Among the changes have been ending the bankers’ bonus cap and instituting reforms in areas as varied as research, short selling, off-exchange share trading, prudential standards for banks and insurance, hedge fund regulations and disclosure rules on investments such as index tracker funds and contracts for difference.
The UK has also regulated new technologies such as AI and cryptoassets under existing UK laws and sought to apply outcomes-based regulation to payments and retail products.
By contrast, the EU has kept stricter rules on unbundling, the bankers’ bonus cap and introduced tailored rules on AI, cryptoassets and IT resilience and security.
But if financial services come up in the broader long-term discussions planned after the summit, it may not be the UK but the EU that broaches the subject.
A report by the think-tank New Financial last month argued that EU financial markets were growing in absolute terms but growing more slowly than many of their peers and going backwards in relative terms.
Political and strategic calculations have also shifted markedly since the bitter divorce six years ago. As Burnham noted, “Britain and the EU are very different to what they were.”
Do you think the EU will shift position on the City?
An early version of this blog started with "Ruari works for TPR" of course that should have been "TPT". Apologies…