First Actuarial warns on knee-jerk reactions to the interest rate rise

knee jerk

With the Bank of England doubling interest rates, First Actuarial predicts a flurry of good and bad pension headlines, but warns of misguided optimism on funding and a rush for the door fuelled by pessimism about transfer values.

Good news stories might appear suggesting that funding deficits of defined benefit (DB) pension schemes will fall as interest rates rise. However, a rise in short-term interest rates could have very little to no impact on longer-dated gilt yields that many pension schemes use to value their liabilities.

Bad news stories might appear suggesting that an interest rate rise will signal a fall in the size of transfer values, frightening some people to rush for the door before they go any lower.

Over the month to 30 September 2017, the FAB Index did not move, with the surplus of the UK’s 6,000 DB pension schemes remaining at £316bn and the funding ratio at 126%.

In contrast, the deficit on the PPF 7800 Index continued to yo-yo, bouncing back over September from a deficit of £220.4bn to £158.0bn.

First Actuarial Partner Rob Hammond said:

“With expectations of an interest rate rise, we saw a rise in gilt yields in September which was reflected in the PPF deficit improvement. Pension schemes that use gilts-plus funding methodology when not invested wholly in gilts, may also have seen a reduction in their funding deficits.

“If long-term gilt yields increase further, funding may improve again. For example, a long-term gilt yield rise of just 0.25% to 0.5% could wipe out the whole of the deficit reported by the PPF 7800 Index.

“However, higher short-term interest rates may not translate into higher long-term gilt yields. Indeed, there was little movement in gilt yields over October, which suggests this has already been priced in. So, sponsors should beware of good news stories that suggest an interest rate rise will be good for pension schemes.

“As shown in September, our FAB Index is virtually immune to changes in gilt yields, as it aligns the value of assets and liabilities, and so will provide a useful barometer to any misguided optimism.”

Hammond added:

“Members should also beware of bad news stories that suggest transfer values will start to fall if the Bank of England raises interest rates. This might not be the case (or may have already happened), and such pessimistic headlines will add yet more scaremongering to that which has spooked many to cash in their valuable defined benefit pension.”


The technical bit…

Over the month to 30 September 2017, the FAB Index did not move, with the surplus in the UK’s 6,000 defined benefit (DB) pension schemes remaining at £316bn.

The deficit on the PPF 7800 Index improved over September from £220.4bn to £158.0bn.

These are the underlying numbers used to calculate the FAB Index.

FAB Index over the last 3 months Assets Liabilities Surplus Funding Ratio ‘Breakeven’ (real) investment return
30 September 2017 £1,524bn £1,208bn £316bn 126% -0.7% pa
31 August 2017 £1,553bn £1,237bn £316bn 126% -0.8% pa
31 July 2017 £1,525bn £1,217bn £308bn 125% -0.7% pa

The overall investment return required for the UK’s 6,000 DB pension schemes to be 100% funded on a best estimate basis – the so called ‘breakeven’ (real) investment return – has remained at around minus 0.7% pa. That means the schemes need an overall actual (nominal) return of 2.9% pa for the assets to meet the liabilities.

The assumptions underlying the FAB Index are shown below:

Assumptions Expected future inflation (RPI) Expected future inflation (CPI) Weighted-average investment return
30 September 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.2% pa
31 August 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.0% pa
31 July 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.1% pa


The tricky bit

The FAB Index is calculated using publicly available data underlying the PPF 7800 Index which aggregates the funding position of 5,794 UK DB pension schemes on a section 179 basis, together with data taken from The Purple Book, jointly published by the PPF and the Pensions Regulator.

The FAB Index is updated on a monthly basis, providing a comparator measure of the financial position of UK DB pension schemes.

Rob Hammond is available for interview. Please contact:

Rob Hammond on 0161 348 7440 or, or Jane Douglas on 0161 348 7463 or



About First Actuarial

First Actuarial is a consultancy providing pension scheme administration, actuarial, investment and consultancy services to a wide range of clients across the UK.

We advise a mixture of open and closed defined benefit schemes with our clients concentrated in the small to medium end of the pension scheme market. Our clients range across a number of sectors including manufacturing, financial services, not for profit organisations and those providing services previously in the public sector.fab hensept


About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in actuaries, advice gap, FCA, pensions and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply