Peter Cameron (video) calls for employers to reopen DB pension schemes.

Peter spoke fluently for over 50 minutes about the advantages he can see in sponsors reopening DB schemes.

It is a speech he delivered to Pensions UK with John Hamilton in the north of England. Today we had a healthy audience interested to hear the story of the UKAS Pension Scheme.

The video is also available on YouTube on this link

There are questions that we couldn’t put to Peter but which we hope will be answered ;

  1. Bob Compton’s question; how close would the UKAS scheme be today to paying the 6oth of salary promised before the scheme moved to 80ths. Is the current surplus up to it?
  2. Have there been questions on whether the scheme complies with the DB auto-enrolment requirements.
  3. Has there been a comparison by the scheme’s advisers of the difference for member between a defined benefit and defined contribution collective pension? (the force behind Rosalind Connor’s question).

We will no doubt hear more from Peter, we unfortunately ran out of time to hear him continue in conversation with new trustee, Derek Benstead.

 

 

Unknown's avatar

About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in pensions and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Peter Cameron (video) calls for employers to reopen DB pension schemes.

  1. Peter Cameron Brown's avatar Peter Cameron Brown says:

    I will endeavour to answer these questions:

    This is an entirely hypothetical question as to answer requires an assumption that the post 2012 actions of the Company and the Trustee would have been the same. 

    What I can say with the benefit of hindsight is that without the reduction in the accrual rate, the subsequent 2012 valuation would have disclosed a past service cost absorbing all the current contributions with no provision for the recovery of a then apparently increasing past service deficit.  This would require the Company to fund deficit recovery contributions in excess of the regular contributions.  This was at a time of general uncertainty following the Global Financial Crisis and the introduction of Quantative Easing challenging all businesses.  The Company’s covenant was also being particularly challenged at this time because of a significant acquisition of another business in 2009 which had still to deliver the benefits of consolidation. 

    Without the reduction in benefits, the company was actively considering the closure of the DB scheme and the substitution of DC contributions.  Because of the continuing need to pay deficit recovery contributions into the DB Scheme plus PPF levies and administration costs, the employer’s contributions to DC pots would be below the contributions into the DB Scheme (5% plus matching contributions up to 10% was a model adopted by comparator organisations at the time). 

    Also in an additional deficit recovery situation, the Scheme’s investment policies would very likely to have switched from growth orientated to a more defensive model.  It was the subsequent maintenance of a growth bias that has led to the current funding position and the surplus which gave rise to the question.

    2. I think this may have been answered later in my presentation, but yes we have been advised that the Scheme (since its auto-enrolment staging date in 2016) is compliant with the Auto-enrolment Regulations (The relevant provisions are in paragraph 36 of Part 10 of the 2010 Regulations).  The only change we had to make was the incorporation of a provision for the future revaluation to pre-retirement accrued benefits in line with the Minimum Rate in the Summary Funding Statement and actuarial valuations under the Technical Provisions.

    3. Since the “shared ambition” DB section was opened and with the subsequent advisory roles of Derek Benstead, the Company has always closely watched the development of CDC pension arrangements.  The possibility of switching to a CDC arrangement was mooted, but as the legislation and CDC offerings developed it has been relegated to the desired alternative if a forced switch to DC became inevitable.  As I emphasised however the Trustee considers all Members interests are best served by a fully open run-on of DB benefits, with the Company being considered in a share of any surplus.

    While the all critical investment performance of a collective CDC fund should theoretically match that of a collective DB fund of similar size and maturity, the fact that administration costs have to be borne by the Members out of the fund, plus the need to service the proprietor’s capital, it is likely that over the long term the benefits provided by CDC would be less than those available to be shared between the Members and the Employer in shared ambition. However in shared ambition, in return for the employer’s interest in any surplus, the “retirement wages” of Members including discretionary awards is guaranteed and cannot be reduced pre and post retirement.   I tried to demonstrate how valuation assumptions and methods have distorted the true position of a DB pension scheme. Although I understand there is some averaging of assumption, there are the same risks in CDC except that they will be directly reflected in the pensions being paid and the reported pensions accrued, with reductions, even if below growth target possible.

    Because any comparison would be so assumption driven, no comparison from the Scheme’s advisors has been sought.  However the Trustee’s Report does include a reference to CDC as an alternative arrangement. 

    We have not yet considered what advice should be given to Members considering a transfer out of shared ambition DB into a CDC arrangement, even though it will not be our responsibility to give that advice. At present elective transfers out of the Scheme are virtually non-existent, even though we regularly provide transfer value quotations. Indeed a surprising high proportion of deferred (and also active) members are over NRD, suggesting they are leaving their pension rights invested in the Scheme for further discretionary revaluations.

    That does not mean that I doubt that CDC provides a strong and viable second best to open accrual shared ambition DB and certainly much better than any non-collective arrangement or commercial offering.

It makes my day to have your comments!