![]() |
Three charts that explain the Milburn Review
A deeper dive into what’s changed – and what hasn’t – about the UK’s NEETs problem over the past twenty years.
NEETs might not be in education, employment or training, but they are (rightly) in the news. The Milburn Review policy proposals for addressing the scandal that near one million young people are NEET are dominating debates this week, so for something different I thought we should dig a bit deeper into the challenge itself. The UK has long had a high number of NEETs. But the purpose of this newsletter is to show you that this continuity absolutely does not mean that things haven’t been changing – indeed there have been some very big changes indeed. Here are 3 charts into the trends and drivers of the problem to bear in mind as we consider the policy recommendations that Alan Milburn has now set out.
The sticky problem
As I’ve covered before, it’s just wrong to say the UK is in some kind of employment crisis: a higher proportion of Brits are working than in all but two out of the last hundred peacetime years. What we do have right now is a low churn labour market (ie little hiring and little firing), on top of something that has been building now for 20 years: a structurally lower employment rate for young people. Youth employment rates never recovered during the 2010s to the highs seen when Tony Blair was Prime Minister. Under the last Conservative government, the employment rate for 16-24 year olds peaked at 55.1%, far short of the over 62% rates seen in the early 2000s. Post-pandemic, youth employment fell again, from 54% in 2022 to around 51% at the time of the 2024 election.
The NEET problem is made up of that reality, plus the UK doing a much worse job than other European countries in post-16 participation in education and training (crucially including studying or training while working). The result is that while many of our international peers have made progress in addressing their own NEETs problem, we have done the opposite: in 2014, the UK was around the European average but by 2025 only Romania recorded a higher NEET rate. Here’s these related long-standing challenges in chart form.
Gender flip
We should not let the persistent scale of the UK’s problem conceal the changes to the nature of it that have taken place under the hood. Most obviously we have seen a huge shift gender wise. Historically it was young women who were more likely to be NEET, by a substantial margin of more than 5% at times during the 2000s. The gap in NEET rates between young men and women narrowed through the 2010s and flipped to young men being more at risk from 2019. By 2024 the male NEET rate was over 3% higher than the female rate.
Why?
A big part of this story is the dramatic decline in teenage pregnancy, which were a huge feature of policy debates in the 1990s and 2000s. That world is gone with conception rates dropping from 52.9 per 1000 women under 20 in 2010 to 28.0 in 2023. The story for young men is very different. The male NEET rate reached 14.6% in 2024 – only falling back 1 percentage point below its post-financial crisis peak of 15.8% in 2011, despite the overall employment rate reaching near record highs.
HInactivity takes the stage
A second important shift to understand is that it is no longer unemployment that is the main driver of the UK’s NEETs problem, as it was in the early 2010s (or indeed the 1980s and 1990s). Youth unemployment – the proportion of young people actively looking for work and available to start – reached a post-2008 peak of 9.3% in 2011. Today’s rate is 5.2%, too high but not far off the 4.7% figure for all age groups.
Our challenge is economic inactivity not unemployment. This is a shift driven by changes amongst NEET young men whose inactivity rates peaked at 8.4% in 2024. And it’s seen in its most acute form when we consider that almost two-thirds of NEETS have never had a job at all.
What do we take from all of this – beyond the status quo is entirely unacceptable? That, as always, we have to understand a problem in detail to fix it (you can read Alan Milburn’s interim report for much more on that front). But crucially that at the core of today’s NEETs challenge is the weakness of our school to work transition, especially for those who do not achieve academically by 16. It’s not the teenager struggling with a child, but the young person struggling without an apprenticeship that is our focus.




Yes - but there is also the other side of the story. The amount of money being taken out of…