Pensions too boring for DWP select committee member


Nigel Mills MP, who sits on the DWP’s Pension Select committee is so committed to his task that he chose to turn up to a DWP committee meeting as a part of the recent pensions debate. He used the time to  play Candy Crush Saga, which was filmed and the film published by the Sun.

If you sign up to the Sun you can watch him playing live!  But like Nigel , you may have better things to do , so you can read the detail in the Guardian here.

Is this a sadder reflection on the state of the pension debate or on Mr Mills?

Those of us who work in pensions are rather keen to get policy right and have a right to be disappointed when someone appointed to govern our pensions chooses to play a silly game on a hand-held device rather than focus on what is being debated.

But having read the  Hansard accounts on  a recent debate in the House, I am not that surprised,  there were a total of 33 new clauses and 72 amendments tabled in one go

The Pension Minister ,Steve Webb, had to spend most of his speech defending the number of amendments from “time-challenged” Conservatives. We now know  what at least one of the MPs was spending his time on (have a read -it’s all on the link).

I wrote last month about former Treasury Secretary, Mark Hoban’s view that the pension industry should look to gaming for ideas on how to engage, educate and empower members, perhaps this was what Nigel had in mind. As XTC sang

We’re only making plans for Nigel, Nigel just needs a helping hand!



MPs lose the right to criticise those in pensions when they are caught playing Candy Crush during pension debates. Having given of our time to help shape the legislative amendments to the Pension Schemes Bill,  we have every right to feel let down when members of our own select committee do not pay attention to the nitty-gritty.

If we want a really dumbed down pension system, we can have compulsion and the kind of pension taxes people get in Australia. But instead we have a more challenging system that gives people pension freedoms.

If the Guardian report is to be believed, it was these very freedoms (on which George Osborne will be campaigning) that Nigel Mills was supposed to be debating.

These freedoms do not come cheap. They require the expense of time and effort. That goes for the people benefiting from them, the people managing them and the people governing them.

Most of us spend many hours doing deeply boring work, it is what we are paid for. If I was found in a meeting playing Candy Crush Saga, I would expect to be on disciplinary, Nigel Mills will probably get away with nothing more than a ribbing.

I could  discuss with Nigel Mills why he preferred Candy Crush Saga to focussing on his job in hand this  Wednesday when we appear on the same panel at a Prospect Debate on “the Future of UK pensions”.

But I’ll resist the temptation, I’d prefer to discuss the agenda (that can be found on the link above). After all, it’s what I’m paid to do.

Candy Addiction


About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in DWP, pensions and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Pensions too boring for DWP select committee member

  1. Gerry Flynn says:

    I doubt if he would have been playing Candy Crush if the Select Committee were discussing their own pension scheme and perhaps turning that into a DC scheme!!!!!

  2. Stephen Gay says:

    Henry – from what I saw in the papers it wasn’t the nitty gritty of bill amendments but the session where the Committee was taking evidence from people like NEST, NOW, Standard, Peoples Pension, L&G on how to make sure AE works well as staging progresses. The session covered things like charges and costs and governance as well as implementation practicalities. The issues at the very heart of our pension endeavours were the ones that couldn’t command his attention.

    • henry tapper says:

      By strange coincidence I have seen Nigel Mills twice in the past two days, on both occasions he was attentive and polite to all.

      He supports Michael Johnson’s tax proposals.

Leave a Reply