First Actuarial- proud to work for you!



I had a nice surprise over breakfast; whizzing through my emails I found that while I’ve gone on holiday, they’ve issued a FAB press release!

50:50 claim by PLSA is “dangerously misleading” says First Actuarial

First Actuarial chastises the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association (PLSA) for its irresponsible claim that “three million members in the weakest schemes only have a 50:50 chance of receiving their full benefits”.

The PLSA also claims that, despite employers spending £120 billion over the last 10 years in special contributions, deficits have remained at over £400 billion. In contrast, First Actuarial’s Best Estimate (FAB) Index improved again in August, with a month-end surplus of £316bn and a funding ratio of 126% across the 6,000 UK defined benefit schemes.

First Actuarial Partner Rob Hammond said:

It is dangerously misleading of the PLSA to claim that there is only a 50:50 chance that some three million members will receive full benefits. And quoting multi-billion pound deficits, without proper context, risks unduly harming confidence in pensions for employers and members.

“Our FAB Index suggests there is a 50:50 chance that the 6,000 UK defined benefit pension schemes have a surplus of over £300 billion. And this is before allowing for scheduled payments of the order of a further £100 billion in place under existing recovery plans.

“So, opinions clearly vary. The problem with the PLSA claim is that it has been presented as fact, when it is simply an opinion – an opinion which could have grave consequences if misinterpreted.”

Hammond added:

“This careless scaremongering plays into the hands of pension scammers who will use it to dupe people away from perfectly sound DB pension schemes.”




The technical bit…

Over the month to 31 August 2017, the FAB Index improved, with the surplus in the UK’s 6,000 defined benefit (DB) pension schemes increasing from £308bn to £316bn.

On the other hand, the deficit on the PPF 7800 index deteriorated over August from £180.1bn to £220.4bn.

These are the underlying numbers used to calculate the FAB Index.

FAB Index over the last 3 months Assets Liabilities Surplus Funding Ratio ‘Breakeven’ (real) investment return
31 August 2017 £1,553bn £1,237bn £316bn 126% -0.8% pa
31 July 2017 £1,525bn £1,217bn £308bn 125% -0.7% pa
30 June 2017 £1,515bn £1,214bn £301bn 125% -0.6% pa

The overall investment return required for the UK’s 6,000 DB pension schemes to be 100% funded on a best estimate basis – the so called ‘breakeven’ (real) investment return – has remained at around minus 0.8% pa. That means the schemes need an overall actual (nominal) return of 2.8% pa for the assets to meet the liabilities.

The assumptions underlying the FAB Index are shown below:

Assumptions Expected future inflation (RPI) Expected future inflation (CPI) Weighted-average investment return
31 August 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.0% pa
31 July 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.1% pa
30 June 2017 3.6% pa 2.6% pa 4.2% pa


FAB index

The FAB Index is calculated using publicly available data underlying the PPF 7800 Index which aggregates the funding position of 5,794 UK DB pension schemes on a section 179 basis, together with data taken from The Purple Book, jointly published by the PPF and the Pensions Regulator.

The FAB Index is updated on a monthly basis, providing a comparator measure of the financial position of UK DB pension schemes.FAB sept




 First Actuarial

I joined First Actuarial nearly eight years ago. It has been a great eight years! Not only have they paid me well but they’ve allowed me to blog as Henry Tapper and supported the Pension Play Pen.

Pension consultancies come in for a lot of stick, but I’d exempt my lot from general criticism. They say what they think and they think deeply. This press release echoes similar comments made on my blog. This is not always the case and we’ve had some famous stand-offs over things that I have written.

But I’m very proud that after so long, we still are friends and that things are set to stay that way. I hope that you feel this way about your employer’s – it makes one hell of a difference!


About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in actuaries, pensions and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to First Actuarial- proud to work for you!

  1. Thanks Henry and Rob.

    It won’t come as any surprise that I wholeheartedly agree with the issue re a dangerous inappropriate and, in my strong view, irresponsible and scaremongering headline message from the PLSA.

  2. henry tapper says:

    Thanks to you too Saroop – this of course is not our position, it is one that is shared collectively by all people who want to restore confidence in pensions. I hope that the PLSA will issue a statement of repentance!

  3. John Mather says:

    Worrying when Actuarial “science” looks more like alchemy especially as a tontine in reverse might describe the protection fund. Evidence such as Wollworth, Kodak, Findus, Thompson Local, DO-IT-ALL,Polaroid,Jessops, HMV, British Leyland, MG ( I could go on) seems to confirm the fears of the PLSA. The Government is so worried about the private sector but does nothing about the £1.8tr reported to be the issue with the Public sector

Leave a Reply