Labour win big – but not well

The Labour vote has delivered it a big majority but it is (at time of writing) less than 2% higher than in 2019. The story of this election is not about more people voting Labour but of less people voting Conservative.

There are currently two conservative parties and the one with the big C has lost so much of its support to Reform that it is facing having not many more than 100 MPs in Westminster.

This was theoretically possible from reading the polls but there is a world of difference between theory and practice. This election was unusual because the theoretical result prior to the Prime Minister calling it was realised on polling day.

This was also an election of personal empowerment.

Voters voted as they thought and not along historical lines or in line with national trends.

Jonathan Ashworth lost his Leicester seat , despite being a potential Cabinet Minister. His constituency preferred a Muslim candidate.  Jeremy Corbyn was returned with a big majority. Kier Starmer had his majority reduced by 6000.

Nothing can be taken for granted going forwards

This election was no respecter of reputations. Liz Truss, Penny Mordaunt, Grant Shapps and Steve Baker are no longer in parliament.  Reform got more votes than the Liberals and not many less than the Conservatives.

But votes do not transfer into seats. This chart shows just how low a voter base, Labour’s super-majority is secured against.

The Reform Party are projected to win only 4 seats on 14% of the poll, the Liberals seats have surged, but few more people have voted for them than four years ago. The distribution of votes in a low turn-out elections still seems manifestly unfair. Though not to the Liberals who for once punched to their weight


Personal stories

Personally I am glad to see Kevin Hollinrake, Jeremy Hunt and Tom Tugendhat back in parliament.

And I am pleased to see this for Yeovil


Grim up north  for Pension Ministers

I am sad to see Guy Opperman leave parliament.

Paul Maynard , our most recent pensions minister also lost his seat in Blackpool North.


Out West – Torsten Bell has been elected.


Different down south

I’m from the South of England so this is how the election impacted people like me.

I am sorry to see the Conservatives squeaked home in Windsor – where my partner lives and  in North Dorset, where my father stood for the Liberals.

North Dorset was not a marginal but the South of England has become of marginal interest to the previously dominant Conservative party


Financial Karma

The most dramatic result of the night, the vote over Liz Truss, shows that no matter how matters have been smoothed over, the nation has not forgiven her for the (£166bn) loss to their pensions and the massive increase in their mortgage payments. I hate to be personal, but Truss’s departure as an MP was as ignominious as her departure from number 10.


The disastrous campaign – a “sobering verdict”.

For years the Liberal party has argued for proportionate representation. This result suggests they are the winners of a first past the post system (along with Labour). Ironically, the Conservative party is the big loser along with Reform. The left used its vote efficiently, the right were hopelessly disorganised.

It is easy to forget this morning that it was the Conservatives who called the timing of this election. It is hard to understand how Sunak and his strategists ignored the threat posed by Nigel Farage.


The Scottish question

The Scottish National Party is predicted to send less than ten MPs down south and having been the third party, are now struggling to have a say in Westminster.

Labour are now back in Scotland as the largest party and by some way. Whatever questions the Scots have, they are likely to be asked with a considerably weaker voice.


A disaster for the Conservative Party

The lowest turn-out, the lowest proportion of the vote for the two major parties and the worst result for the Conservatives since the 1830 reform act.

The Conservative party, a massively well funded party that until this election owned the majority of the British media has lost control not just of itself, but of its embedded support.

Farage clearly feels his job disabling the Conservatives is done. He is now turning his sights on the Labour Party whose hold on its vast majority is supported by only a third of a very low vote.

Unless the Conservatives can find a new narrative, a competent Labour Government has little to fear from them but a lot to fear from Reform.

The saddest thing for Conservatives, entitled for so long to power, is that they are currently a political irreverence.

For the first time ever, the House of Parliament sits in a Labour constituency

 


 

About henry tapper

Founder of the Pension PlayPen,, partner of Stella, father of Olly . I am the Pension Plowman
This entry was posted in pensions. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Labour win big – but not well

  1. Brian G says:

    Bit of a tragedy that so many voters put their cross in the Reform box, and it is a matter of great concern that such extreme populist nonsense is considered to be the way forward for millions of people. Given how difficult it will be for Labour to sort out the mess left by the Conservative clown show (who have also been as economically illiterate as the Reform manifesto) it is a great worry that the Right could threaten our way of life. It is hard not to imagine Labour becoming unpopuar as they will need to make some difficult choices. The NHS and social care, and most public services are in crisis, and it will take more than 5 years to repair them. There is nothing that Farage and Tice say that is worth listening to if you have any understanding of economics, and their vile racist undertones cause division instead of harmony. But it’s easy to see them getting a bigger foothold at the next election when people become impatient and more disillusioned. Fantastic to see so many tory big guns voted out. In Starmer and Reeves first past the post has delivered a competent, compassionate capable prime minister and Chancellor. Regardless of political beliefs, we need a capable competent cabinet, and the Labour front bench walks all over the nincompoop tory shitshow we have endured for 14 years.

  2. Derek Benstead says:

    Labour’s candidate in Leicester South was Jonathan Ashworth. Jonathan Reynolds retained his Stalybridge and Hyde constituency.

Leave a Reply to Brian GCancel reply