Site icon Pensions Mutual; Making your money work as hard as you do

A letter to the Times . Why it’s gone viral- post Milburn.

henry tapper
28 minutes ago

This letter makes sense to me. We can’t take on youngsters even as interns without tying ourselves up in knots – this is pointed out to us by the recruitment agencies which we currently can’t afford.

We want people to be at work as soon as they leave education , whether that’s  from school or college.

I have written to Lesley Sheffield, thanking him for this. He is right, we did not need the Milburn “inquest” to know what Milburn said. Government now has a job to encourage employers and their recruiters to seek out not avoid those looking for their first job.

We all can remember how we got our first job and , knowing as I do, the kind of reader that I get, you’ve probably the milk train worked for you. It’s not working for graduates nearly as well and it’s no good at all for the vast majority of Neets who had little expectation when joining the dole queue (as we used to call it).

To finish, here’s Fraser Nelson with his reaction to reading Lesley Sheffield.


The missing Milburn Index: what it costs to hire the young

A letter-writer to The Times just might have just solved the Neets mystery

Fraser Nelson
Nov 17, 2026
There’s an intriguing line midway through the Milburn review suggesting someone should graph up the cost of hiring young people. “The Government should publish every two years a Youth Employment Cost Index which itemises the financial impact of its decisions on the youth labour market,” it declared.

A great idea, but why every two years? Such an index – let’s call it the Milburn Index – could be compiled in two hours. Had it been compiled before now, it could have added perspective to the debate – especially the role of government-set policies in pricing some young people out of the market. By coincidence, a marvellous letter in The Times that morning from a manager of an East Anglia employment agency made the same point. “It is politicians who have largely created this situation” wrote Lionel Sheffield. Both problems and solutions, he added, are in hiding plain sight.

Milburn went as far as he dared in alluding to this. “Wage costs for young people aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage have increased by 65 per cent over the last five years” says the Milburn report (para 263). That’s just minimum wage and doesn’t adjust for inflation. But let’s build his Youth Employment Cost Index on a real-terms basis. What do we see? Precisely the problem that Lionel Sheffield outlines.

  • A 48pc real-terms rise in the cost of hiring a young person vs 2011/12, from £17,600 a year to £26,100, in today’s money.
  • More than half of that rise, £4,700, has come in the last three years.
  • And of that, £2,600 has come from decisions taken since Labour came to power: the steep rises in the youth minimum wage and the increase in employer National Insurance.
  • The other £2,100 increase was from Jeremy Hunt: the pre-election extension of the full National Living Wage to 21- and 22-year-olds. “The largest ever cash increase in the National Living Wage” he boasted in his 2024 Budget.

Here’s the picture:-

The Milburn Index, were it to be compiled, would barely move for the first half of the 2010s. A young worker cost slightly less in 2014 than in 2011, because youth minimum wages rose more slowly than prices. It drifted up through the late 2010s, then: kapoosh. In just three years the Milburn Index has gone from 122 to 148.

We can break down the components thusly:-

This is a crude first stab. It tracks a fixed mix of 18 to 24-year-olds, weighted by how many of each age are in work: about a third 18-20, a third 21-22 and a third 23-24. Each is assumed to work full time and the mix fixed so that the index measures the cost of hiring, not changes in who gets hired.

1. The rising minimum wage: up £6,850 a year since 2011/12. By far the biggest factor. The youth rate for 18 to 20-year-olds has risen from £4.98 an hour to £10.85, and the age for the full adult rate has fallen from 25 to 21.

2. Employer National Insurance: up £1,960. For many years, employers were taxed 14pc of whatever salary they paid above a threshold of about £8,000-£9,000. In Apr25, Rachel Reeves raised the rate to 15pc and – worst part – the threshold came down to £5,000. Suddenly, hiring a 22-year-old becomes £1,000 a year more expensive.

3. The under-21 NI relief: saves £800. The one change that went the other way. Since Apr15, employers have paid no National Insurance on workers under 21: a pre-election tax cut. “When a business is giving a young person a chance in life we’re going to support them not tax them,” said Osborne. To be fair to him, the Milburn Index shows the costs of hiring the young were stable when he was Chancellor. His tax cut is today worth about £800 a year on the typical young hire and grew more valuable when the NI rate rose. This is why 18, 19 and 20-year-olds all cost the same to employ – but the cost jumps at 21.

4. Workplace pensions: costs £370. Auto-enrolment began in 2012 under David Cameron and applies from age 22. Employers must contribute 3pc of salary above a threshold of £6,240 a year. For our Milburn Index, we assume a large employer.

5. The apprenticeship levy: £120. Another Tory brainwave in the 2015 manifesto. Since 2017, employers with a payroll over £3 million pay 0.5pc of it. Osborne sold the levy as making big firms pay their fair share of training, to fund three million apprenticeships. In his 2015 Budget he bravely castigated large companies who “take a free ride on the system” by leaving training to others. But no, the Tories would oversee a surge in apprenticeships! The policy was a disaster.

Milburn looks at this debacle, calling it “a payroll tax”. It was never ringfenced for apprenticeships and (no surprise) HM Treasury keeps part of what employers pay: about £460 million. Osborne’s “unspoken compromise”, as Milburn puts it, was to let employers decide how the money was spent. They did the rational thing and used it to retrain staff they already had, often older and at higher levels, rather than take on school-leavers.

The result is an apprenticeship system that Milburn calls “unique amongst comparable countries”: it covers all ages and all skill levels, yet has some of the lowest take-up by the young. As the above graph shows, starts have crashed. Only one in five apprenticeships now goes to a 16 to 18-year-old, and just 4pc of apprentices under 25 were previously NEET.

Also since the 2024 Hunt budget – which our index exposes as the big bang in the cost of employing the young – the industries that hire the young have seen vacancies decline most (hotels, recreation, retail, hospitality).

What’s left out of my Milburn Index, which a full government index should probably add:

  • Statutory sick pay. The Employment Rights Act removes the waiting days from Apr26.
  • The new guaranteed-hours rules, whose costs aren’t yet known.
  • Hiring subsidies on the other side of the ledger: the Youth Contract, Kickstart, and Milburn’s proposed £3,000 payment for taking on a Neet.
  • The Employment Allowance, which cuts NI for small firms.

Milburn’s point is that no one in Whitehall has summed the costs up. They all talk as if they’re giving away money (pace Hunt) while underestimating the cumulative impact. Milburn is right to say this should be considered, but wrong to suggest it only needs to be done every two years. The index should be published immediately. The Neets crisis would still exist without these extra costs, but they are an important part of understanding this problem. I’ve just added my ‘Milburn Index’ to the Neets page of my data library for reference meanwhile.

Share this:

  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Increases to mandatory workplace pension contributions kicked into the next decade
    Date
    November 18, 2026
    In relation to
    pensions
  • Three charts that explain the Milburn Review -Torsten Bell
    Date
    November 18, 2026
    In relation to
    pensions
  • The young are turning to unpaid internship, so are young retirees!
    Date
    November 17, 2026
    In relation to
    pensions
Categories: pensions
Tags: Fraser Nelson, Lionel Sheffield, Rapid recruitment
Leave a Comment

Pensions Mutual; Making your money work as hard as you do

Back to top
Exit mobile version