Andrew Tully is writing for financial advisers
I take one statement of Andrew’s
“it’s clear that creating a suitable default retirement strategy is fundamentally more challenging than default enrolment”
This is what “pensions” were about and there were two options. The first was to use the money you’d accumulated to purchase an an annuity . The second was to manage the pension collectively, creating a pool to pay income for a lifetime.
Actually thee is nothing new with the options being considered. The annuity can be bought at retirement or deferred and purchased with money much later on, in Nest’s case the default into which most savers will be tipped will start at 67 and the annuity will be bought if the saver survives to 85. This is called flex and fix and there’s a middle way where some annuity is bought at retirement and the rest is used to supplement it with a drawdown from an individual pot. We can call “money purchase” flex and fix or fix and flex” but it comes down how to turn pots to pension.
As for collective pensions, there is nothing to it. It could be called “undefined benefit” because like drawdown, nothing is guaranteed and success depends on managing the income for as long as it’s needed. The better the money is invested the higher the inflation on the income the worse – the lower the income. As with an individual there is a chance the drawdown will go down when market returns are very poor. Here there are no individual pots to be turned to pensions, just one big one, paying out pensions – till infinity (in principle).
All that has moved on since the last century is that defined benefit is now collective (CDC) pension and is undefined. The only thing that has changed with the money purchase is that it is now managed by the pension manager via the trustees.
I know that Andrew is describing “guided retirement” as fundamentally more difficult and it may seem so. But it isn’t. It’s just reverting to collective pensions and money purchase and the only thing that’s different is the option to open the door and walk outside into “pension freedom”.
If I was an IFA (which I used to be) , I’d be inviting my clients and prospects to step away from “guided retirement” and show people the garden – where everyone can have retirement finance as they like. Would I like my retirement in that garden? Well I doubt it. Some people will and some won’t and some will be their own financial adviser with help from whatever help they feel they need.
If I was addressing “guided retirement” with a client I would be putting things in something like this way. Of course most people retiring today will have some guaranteed pension (which is how the pensions of the last century developed this year). All should have something by way of state pension and the pension pot will have differing importance, but one way or another, it is likely that a question about “guided retirement” will arise and if there’s one thing an IFA should be thinking is that it’s nothing to do with them.

